Home Strategic Sustainability: Leveraging Materiality Assessment for Unified ESG Impact


When evaluating business ESG initiatives, there can be many competing priorities. Different stakeholders often care about specific projects to different extents, depending on their own perceived value or where they have direct involvement. So, how do you get everyone on the same page? 


Defining Materiality Assessment 

Materiality assessment is a critical framework that helps businesses make informed decisions and prioritize their efforts.  At its core, materiality assessment is the process used by organizations to identify, evaluate, and prioritize ESG issues that are most relevant to the stakeholders and business operations. ESG issues are typically scored by different stakeholder groups based on their importance and criticality to stakeholders and the business’s ongoing success.

The concept of materiality assessment for sustainability issues was popularized by the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), but materiality is rooted in financial disclosure. The SASB revised its definition of materiality in 2020 to: “For SASB’s standard-setting process, information is financially material if omitting, misstating, or obscuring it could be material. This is rooted in the assessments users make based on their considerations of short-, medium-, and long-term financial performance and enterprise value.”

Materiality In a Changing Business Landscape 

A materiality assessment is becoming a classic analysis for sustainability consulting firms, but its use should not be limited to when you are doing a strategic review. A company ownership or industry dynamics change should trigger you to consider materiality.

Unlike mandatory regulations such as the SEC proposal rule, CSRD, or NFRD, companies are not obligated to conduct a materiality assessment. They will not incur penalties for not completing this assessment.


Materiality Assessments: Why They Matter for Sustainable Business Practices

Conducting a materiality assessment offers several advantages. Firstly, it enables companies to identify and define the most suitable long-term emissions reduction and people development strategies while evaluating risks and leveraging available opportunities. Engaging stakeholders is crucial during this process, as their perspectives on sustainability management profoundly influences the assessment.

Furthermore, a materiality assessment enhances the organization’s transparency and reputation. The effort to conduct such an assessment showcases the company’s dedication to enhancing sustainability practices. Other primary benefits include improved sustainability reporting, better Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) reports, enhanced ability to monitor sustainability progress and adjust plans accordingly and more optimal resource allocation.

However, while materiality assessments offer numerous benefits, they also present challenges. It is necessary to incorporate diverse stakeholder viewpoints and prioritize them to align with business goals, which can be complex. Additionally, successful materiality assessments often extend beyond a company’s operations, requiring evaluation of their value and supply chain. This adds another layer of complexity to the process. In recent years, criticism of materiality assessment has focused on the lack of rigor typically applied when businesses conduct an evaluation. A recent management review suggests that ‘Materiality Assessment is an Art, not a Science,’ as the chosen materiality perspective influences how the other steps are conducted. Selection bias arises when firms rely solely on their network. While stakeholders from their network may be familiar with the firm and understand its impact, this approach can lead to an overemphasis on issues with immediate financial implications. Longer-term concerns may be neglected, undermining the purpose of conducting the assessment in the first place.

Prospects 2024: Materiality in Focus

In summation, a meticulous materiality assessment stands as the linchpin to astute decision-making, cultivating robust stakeholder bonds, and bolstering a company’s standing in the market. This discerning review bestows businesses the power to channel their endeavors towards pivotal domains, paving the way for enduring sustainability and triumph, fortified by the collective wisdom of all stakeholders.

Looking ahead to 2024, a tidal wave of scrutiny will wash over materiality assessments. Firms will invest augmented resources, drawing an expanded cadre of stakeholders into the fold, or they may take the audacious step of reevaluating their approach altogether. The shift promises a landscape where discernment and accountability reign supreme, propelling businesses toward unparalleled heights of impact and influence.

Start your Materiality Assessment today to unlock informed strategies, strengthen stakeholder relationships, and lead in responsible business practices that make a lasting impact on our world.

Take your first step toward a Materiality Assessment, contact us now!

Need a thought partner?

Share your focus area or question to engage with our Analysts through the Business Objectives service.

Submit My Business Objective

Our Clients

Our long-standing clients include some of the worlds leading brands and forward-thinking corporations.